terror in delhi 10/29
Wednesday, March 01, 2006
  President Bush Visits India: Media Roundup

After an initial mini roundup, we now present more press editorials and op-ed pieces on the Indo-US relations in general and President Bush’s visit in particular:

The New York Sun has an historical take on President Bush’s visit when India is rediscovering its rich entrepreneurial roots advocated by Vallabhai Patel only to be stiffled by a socialist-minded Nehru. The New York Times chides President Bush to have ignored larger issues like poverty eradication and sustainable energy development and instead excessively concentrate on “a nuclear deal that shouldn't have been initiated to begin with”. It then demands the U.S. Congress to reject the deal should it be presented for ratification. The New York Newsday cheerfully praises the new U.S. ties with India as “most important relationships of the 21st century” and concluding, “As a pragmatic compromise the nuclear agreement has merit, especially if it becomes the basis on which to build closer ties with Asia's emerging geopolitical giant”.

The Los Angeles Times has a guarded response to the nuclear deal saying ‘the price is too high’. Its opposition to the deal is rooted in the fear that similar demands will be made by other states like Iran or North Korea. The San Francisco Chronicle credits President Bush for ‘tightly weaving India’s future’ with America’s own but expresses sceptism if he can bring back a deal acceptable to the U.S. Congress. The Baltimore Sun in an editorial dubs the President’s visit as an ‘important turning point’ to the Indo-US relations. It further argues that a ‘no deal’ at this point should not stop the two countries from further pursuing ‘big strides’ towards even closer relations.

Daniel Sneider writing for the San Jose Mercury News while welcoming the Presidential visit also cautions against falling into three ‘pitfalls’. First, India may not be willing to play the role of a bulwark against an ascending China. Second, Mr. Sneider while welcoming a ‘reasonable’ form of the July 18 nuclear deal, also warns on the resistance the Prime Minister might face from Indian political parties. Third - while the growing Indian economy provides immense opportunities for the U.S., it can equally also present ‘competitive challenges’. Jim Hoagland of the Washington Post opines that the nuclear agreement is a ‘creative’ diplomatic effort as part of the “Rice Doctrine” through a “realistic reshaping of the global non-proliferation rules” to help India which has been ‘scrupulously’ adhering to non-proliferation principles. David Ignatius again of the Washington Post acknowledging the need for nuclear power for a vast country like India also categorically rules out any comparison with Iran wanting to imitate India’s nuclear deal since “The same rules don't apply to both; one has shown that it is benign and the other behaves like a global outlaw”.

The Financial Times UK, while calling the nuclear deal as ‘bold’ and giving solid arguments in its favor (India’s good non-proliferation record in contrast to Pakistan’s ‘nuclear Wal-Mart’, environmental reasons and the ‘China’ factor) nevertheless calls for a more ‘credible’ separation plan from India rather than hurriedly accept a ‘watered-down’ version of the deal. Finally, The Times UK in an editorial states that India should respond positively to the fact that “America’s ties with Pakistan are no longer a hindrance to the strategic partnership with Delhi that the Bush Administration seeks”. It further points that while India has big strides to make in developing infrastructure and boosting investment in primary education, an open society with free speech and strong political and business institutions will be on its side on the path towards its rapid emergence.

Cross-posted in Desicritics.org.

Hey cynical, you do write well. Have been reading ur post regularly on dc. But i would like to ask you one thing, that you honor the spirit of 9/11, 7/7 etc., but what abt parliament attack? you havent included them.
mayank: Thanks. Well, those links are no way comprehensive. We can include other likes too like Akshardam, Ayodhya temple, Mumbai blasts, etc. Indeed, there won't be space left in the side bar. The excellent SATP folks have been covering them very well - hence it has been linked.

CN: excellent summary. NYT's credibility just keeps sinking. It's one thing to be left-wing and coherent - quite another to be left-wing and dumb.
libertarian: Thanks. you are right. Indian folks reading only the NYT will think that the whole of America despises India. Me too was pleasantly surprised to read other positive opinions. It is time to keep track of such people.

Your round up almost reflected mine which I put up here
BangaloreGuy: Good effort too. Great minds think alike ;-)
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home
news and views about the terror attacks in new delhi on october the 29th 2005. alerting citizens of all civilized nations on new terror threats.

About Me

Name:cynical nerd
Contact: cynical.nerd@gmail.com
Blogger Profile

Never forget

The victims of terror

We Salute

The spirit of 9/11 & 7/7 & 3/11

Counter Terror

Inside Laskhar
Breeding Ground of Terror
Root Cause My A**
G.O.A.T. Comes Home To Roost
Taking The Fight To The Enemy
Terror Strikes Varanasi: Plus ca change ...

Media/Public Opinion

Shocking Hypocrisy
Candle Kisser™®© Alert
Stop This Cricketing Madness
Why Are We Gloating?

India-US nuclear agreement

N-deal: More Clarity Needed
N-deal: An Isolated PMO
N-deal: Deconstructing The ‘Cheerleaders’
N-deal: Deconstructing the Non-Proliferation Lobby
N-deal: Looking Ahead Boldly
N-agreement: Putting the cards on the table


Uncle’s Long Arm
Iran's Misplaced Anger
India's Energy Security
Balochistan Blues: Another Bangladesh In the Making?


Fun Quiz
Master G.O.A.T.
CNN: Europe's Communal Tensions
Pervix Meretricix™®© Goes to Helvetix


Bharat Rakshak
Indian Maverick
Observer Research Foundation
Secular Right
South Asia Analysis Group
South Asia Terrorism Portal
The Acorn

Blogs that link here


October 2005 / November 2005 / December 2005 / January 2006 / February 2006 / March 2006 / April 2006 /

Stop Terror against the Indian people